読み取り専用

フォーラムは現在、読み取り専用のアーカイブとなっています。.

バグ報告やプラットフォームに関する質問はこちら → [email protected]

私たちのコミュニティはDiscordとYouTubeで活動しています。ぜひ参加してください!

ご参加ください Discord YouTube

自動取引とテクニカル分析は効果があるのでしょうか?

71件の回答

マイキー

顧客、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、856件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #114477

以下の議論の続報:

 

https://strategyquant.com/forum/topic/3255-portfolio-doing-well/

 

新しいトピックを作成しようと思いました。. 

 

この点について意見を共有したい方は、ぜひ教えてください。(機能するかどうかは分かりませんが、その証拠はこちらです。)正しい答えは一つもないので、考えを広く開いて、できる限り科学的に議論しましょう。.

 

myfxbookの検証済みの結果に関するリンクは歓迎します。これはあなた自身のシステムである必要はありません。ただ、何年にもわたってトレーダーが実質的な利益を上げてきたことを証明するものでなければなりません。個人的には、過去の価格データだけでは実現できないと考えています。過去のデータをただ計算するだけでは限界があります。今現在の市場の感情や、近い将来起こり得る事柄を知る必要があります。こうした点に関するご提案は歓迎します。.

 

テクニカル分析だけが通用していたなら、パブの裏で外国為替の億万長者が次々と現れていただろう。私が目にしているのは、コースや書籍、ソフトウェアを販売して金持ちになる人々だけだ。もしあなたが、富裕な外国為替の個人トレーダーがいる場所を聞いてみると、彼らはすべて奇妙な場所のどこかに姿を消し、成功を明かさずにいるだけだ。.

 

 

 

 

0

エイジス

カスタマー、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、10件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134361

 

 

So my current conclusion is retail forex trading is a zero sum game.  Sure you might have an edge for a few months against the market, but your system will give it all back “when the market changes”.  You don’t know using TA when the market has changed, and by the time you figure it out you are in deep drawdown and have to close at a loss.

 

Show us what you’ve come with so far, and maybe the members here will try to improve upon it. Most of the systems generated by SQ have long periods of stagnation, so a few months isn’t going to tell you much of anything. Also, if you’re ignoring FA, you’re wasting your time. You won’t find an edge without incorporating FA into your trading.

0

マイキー

顧客、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、856件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134362

 Also, if you’re ignoring FA, you’re wasting your time. You won’t find an edge without incorporating FA into your trading.

 

こんにちは、,

 

How and in what way do you incorporate fundamental analysis (FA) into your automated trading and SQ?  This is something I’m working on at the moment.  Any ideas or guidance on this appreciated.

 

よろしくお願いいたします。,

 

マイク

0

Tomas Matejka

管理者、sq-ultimate、2件の返信.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134379

My opinion is that statistical approach (pure technical) to trading is sufficient and it does not matter whether you daytrade, autotrade, do position trading or selling options. There is a opinion around that as soon as you get news market has already discounted it. But there are paid and costly services (news feeds) that can provide some type of edge depending on what you play (HFT, hedgers etc). I believe there is no need to ‘predict’ price movement using FA to have an edge. Marty Schwarz confirms that too

 

Did you make a complete transition from fundamental to technical analysis?
Absolutely. I always laugh at people who say, “I’ve never met a rich technician.” I love that! It is
such an arrogant, nonsensical response. I used fundamentals for nine years and got rich as a
technician.

 

Maybe when incorporating FA you may get some additional % to your WIN% but who knows 🙂

0

マイキー

顧客、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、856件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134381

My opinion is that statistical approach (pure technical) to trading is sufficient and it does not matter whether you daytrade, autotrade, do position trading or selling options. There is a opinion around that as soon as you get news market has already discounted it. But there are paid and costly services (news feeds) that can provide some type of edge depending on what you play (HFT, hedgers etc). I believe there is no need to ‘predict’ price movement using FA to have an edge. Marty Schwarz confirms that too

 

 

Maybe when incorporating FA you may get some additional % to your WIN% but who knows 🙂

 

トーマスさん、こんにちは,

 

Marty Schwartz had a seat on the American Stock Exchange in the early 1980’s trading stocks and futures.  So he had a view of trader activity and sentiment outside of blind TA.  Very different from a retail forex trader I would say.

 

If he could make money using price feeds and TA alone, why did he spend a fortune buying a seat there?  🙂

 

よろしくお願いいたします。,

 

マイク

0

クローネックス / イヴァン・フーデツ

Customer, bbp_participant, community, sq-ultimate, contributor, author, editor, 268件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134386

And this is proof that quantitative trading does not work???? Marty schwartz and this story lol.

Odoslané z SM-G900F pomocou Tapatalku

0

エイジス

カスタマー、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、10件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134390

Inefficiencies are driven by fundamental forces – not technicals. Purely technical driven systems are reactive instead of proactive, and therefore, they offer no edge to the retail trader unless he/she has access to order flow.

I actually don’t believe in SQ. I purchased it over a year ago and I wish I could get a refund.

0

エイジス

カスタマー、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、10件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134392

SQ’s license is not transferable.

0

マイキー

顧客、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、856件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134393

My hope for the future is that SQ4 is flexible enough to feed external data (indicator data if you like) from sources that are not derived from past prices.  Such feeds would include trader sentiment, economic news events and other such feeds. 

 

Aegis has hit the nail on the head, in that TA is reactive. I like my analogy of driving a car.  With TA you have to navigate a winding road along a mountain edge, but you are only allowed to look out of the rear view windows.

 

FA enables you so have some kind of view of the road ahead.

0

tbu

カスタマー、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、11件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134394

I think you are too negative. Do you have an evidence that TA and SQ doesnt work? The most of professional trader uses TA beside FA, why?

SQ is a very good program and its robustnost tests are great, better than Daniel Fernandez’ tools. By the way, I know him for about 5 years, he is clever and hardworking man.

Do you consider a length of stagnation and max DD in your strategies? It seams to me you create a strategy, run it and after several days/weeks you remove it, because it is not succesful. And again and again. I think the strategy needs more time to say how successful is it.

 

I sugest to send us you “unsuccessful” strategies and we will have a look, do tests of robustness and tell you our opinion…

0

マイキー

顧客、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、856件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134395

I think you are too negative. Do you have an evidence that TA and SQ doesnt work? The most of professional trader uses TA beside FA, why?

SQ is a very good program and its robustnost tests are great, better than Daniel Fernandez’ tools. By the way, I know him for about 5 years, he is clever and hardworking man.

Do you consider a length of stagnation and max DD in your strategies? It seams to me you create a strategy, run it and after several days/weeks you remove it, because it is not succesful. And again and again. I think the strategy needs more time to say how successful is it.

 

I sugest to send us you “unsuccessful” strategies and we will have a look, do tests of robustness and tell you our opinion…

 

こんにちは,

 

I’m not being too negative. SQ is a fantastic piece of software and has been invaluable to me.  I think the failings are not with SQ, but limitations of TA in the forex market for retail traders.  Maybe other markets work better with TA, such as stocks, indices, commodities. I don’t know.

 

I cannot prove TA doesn’t work, I was opening up a discussion around the limitations of TA alone.  As it stands SQ is a tool that relies on TA.  If TA alone doesn’t work, then SQ will never find strategies that are robust for more than a few weeks.

 

What does seem to be very rare is any kind of verified account in myfxbook that is consistent and with low drawdown.  Seems trading profitably without months of drawdown is a rare feat.

 

If anyone has any FA insights to share that might give TA and extra edge, I’d be interested to hear them.

0

daveM

サブスクライバー、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、カスタマー、sq-ultimate、108件の返信.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134516

I have built a couple ea’s that make some money, using higher time frames. No luck on the faster time frames.

 

Considering the work I have had to do to eek out some profits, I am not getting paid well.

 

I have been using 4 hour and 8 hour charts most of the time…… and plan to convert to daily charts.  I find that the longer charts offer to me a lower risk.

0

tnickel

カスタマー、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、sq-ultimate、494件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134529

This EA works too.

The time period is 5 years.

 

http://www.wallstreet-forex.com/

https://monitortool.jimdofree.com/

0

マイキー

顧客、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、856件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134530

This EA works too.

The time period is 5 years.

 

http://www.wallstreet-forex.com/

 

http://forums.babypips.com/newbie-island/53684-guide-using-recognising-myfxbook-accounts.html

 

4. Myfxbook uses gain and absolute gain.

Gain is a time weighted listed – ie: the gain from the initial deposit. The absolute gain is the overall return on investment (ROI). In my opinion this is the most important. The ‘gain’ can be manipulated by inserting $1 as the initial deposit. The trader then adds $100 at a later date and makes a further $100. The absolute gain or ROI is $100. The myfxbook will list the absolute gain as a little under 100%. However, it will list the gain as 100 000% because the account has gained $100 from an initial deposit of $1.

 
 
Looking at wallstreet forex EA:
 
  • Gain:+649.63%
  • Abs. Gain: +106.29%

 

Note the EA author has been depositing money into the account, making the gain look rather good….sell robots, deposit the money into the live account.. bingo… gain goes up and up….

0

マイキー

顧客、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、856件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134533

I bet you wouldn’t mind 

  • Abs. Gain: +106.29%

This week I have missed the naysayers and the ‘it can’t be done‘ Brigade because they put a smile on my face.      

 

106% over 5 years?  Could probably get that from a bank account with compound interest at zero risk. 🙂

0

マイキー

顧客、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、856件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #134536

Tell me the name of the bank so I can deposit ALL my life savings in it.  Seriously, I hope (for your sake) you are joking  

 

Bank of Magic Unicorns. 😉

0

15件の返信を表示中 - 16 - 30件目 (全71件中)

← 1 2 3 4 5 →