読み取り専用

フォーラムは現在、読み取り専用のアーカイブとなっています。.

バグ報告やプラットフォームに関する質問はこちら → [email protected]

私たちのコミュニティはDiscordとYouTubeで活動しています。ぜひ参加してください!

ご参加ください Discord YouTube

戦略における逆入

6件の返信

マウロ

定期購入者、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、2件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #115013

こんにちは、,

 

I have a logic problem, One strategy and another strategy with same value but reverse entry condition, for ex, LongEntryCondition = (RSI(4) < Stoch(9, 3, 3))….. and the another is LongEntryCondition = (RSI(4) > Stoch(9, 3, 3))…. and I cant figure out a valid explanation of why the entries order are different. diferent time, price, etc… the correct logic must be the exact same order but in reverse, one Buy and the another is Sell.

 

for ex:

 

Here is a Strategy, ( a losing strategy):

 

 

——————————————————————————————————————————————————–

  Tested on EURJPY, M15, 01.08.2012 – 14.11.2014
  Spread: 16.0, Slippage: 2.0, Min distance of stop from price: 5.0
====================================================================
== 入会条件
====================================================================
LongEntryCondition = (RSI(4) < Stoch(9, 3, 3))
ShortEntryCondition = (RSI(4) > Stoch(9, 3, 3))
====================================================================
== 入札命令
====================================================================
— 長いエントリ
もし LongEntryConditionが true なら
   if No position is open then Buy on open at Market;
   Stop Loss = (1.51 * ATR(65)) pips;
   Profit Target = (2.19 * ATR(30)) pips;
   // Move SL to BE (on close)
   Move Stop Loss to Entry price when in profit at least (1.87 * ATR(17)) pips;
}
— ショートエントリー
もし ShortEntryConditionが true なら
   if No position is open then Sell on open at Market;
   Stop Loss = (1.51 * ATR(65)) pips;
   Profit Target = (2.19 * ATR(30)) pips;
   // Move SL to BE (on close)
   Move Stop Loss to Entry price when in profit at least (1.87 * ATR(17)) pips;
}
——————————————————————————————————————————————————–
And the same Strategy but reverse EntryCondiion:
——————————————————————————————————————————————————–
 Tested on EURJPY, M15, 01.08.2012 – 14.11.2014
  Spread: 16.0, Slippage: 2.0, Min distance of stop from price: 5.0
——————————————————————–
====================================================================
== 入会条件
====================================================================
LongEntryCondition = (RSI(4) > Stoch(9, 3, 3))
ShortEntryCondition = (RSI(4) < Stoch(9, 3, 3))
====================================================================
== 入札命令
====================================================================
— 長いエントリ
もし LongEntryConditionが true なら
   if No position is open then Buy on open at Market;
   Stop Loss = (1.51 * ATR(65)) pips;
   Profit Target = (2.19 * ATR(30)) pips;
   // Move SL to BE (on close)
   Move Stop Loss to Entry price when in profit at least (1.87 * ATR(17)) pips;
}
— ショートエントリー
もし ShortEntryConditionが true なら
   if No position is open then Sell on open at Market;
   Stop Loss = (1.51 * ATR(65)) pips;
   Profit Target = (2.19 * ATR(30)) pips;
   // Move SL to BE (on close)
   Move Stop Loss to Entry price when in profit at least (1.87 * ATR(17)) pips;
}
——————————————————————————————————————————————————–

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

why the open time, price, are different?, in this is not big difference, but in another have are too much difference.

 

 

 

 

0

マビ

Customer、bbp_participant、community、sq-ultimate、252件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #136490

You don´t think it has to do with the spread and slippage ?

0

geektrader

顧客、bpb_participant、コミュニティ、503件の回答。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #136503

You can´t turn a losing strategy into a winning strategy by reversing the entry conditions. The reason both lose is because of spread. Stick to finding winning strategies right from the start and forget the losing ones, you can´t make them winning ones by reversing them.


🚀 自動化された外国為替戦略開発であなたの優位性を引き出せます 🚀

1987年から開始された歴史的な外国為替データ。28ペア、M1、99%エラーなし、生涯無料アップデート

0

しきい値

カスタマー、bbp_participant、コミュニティ、722件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #136506

+1, if every losing strategy’s opposite rules made it into a winning strategy, trading would be a lot easier. Sometimes it works, but rarely.

The entry condition on this particular strategy isnt why its losing- its entry prices and exits are. But the entry condition also isnt helping very much.

Test them in MT4 visual mode. You will see both these strategies are not very different ultimately, even if you switch the entry conditions.

0

マビ

Customer、bbp_participant、community、sq-ultimate、252件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #136507

Looking at some of the looser and i would say also good strategies that SQ generates is many times totally against trading “guru´s”  teachings of a winning system but  found to be profitable by SQ. Maybe SQ  should have an option to test the reverse conditions as well automatically before discarding the generated strategy as crap. However most probably Mark and his team already tested this feature.

0

geektrader

顧客、bpb_participant、コミュニティ、503件の回答。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #136508

It makes really no sense to waste CPU cycles on such an extra test. The random generation finds such “reverse” strategies in any case because it generates them the normal way anyway by randomness, no need to test losing ones one more time extra the other way around and double processing time to find strategies. In 8 years I´ve not come across a SINGLE case where a losing strategy could be winning if reversing it´s rules, not a single time.


🚀 自動化された外国為替戦略開発であなたの優位性を引き出せます 🚀

1987年から開始された歴史的な外国為替データ。28ペア、M1、99%エラーなし、生涯無料アップデート

0

マビ

Customer、bbp_participant、community、sq-ultimate、252件の返信。.

プロフィールを表示

10年前 #136509

Thats what i thought , would just waste resources.

0

6件の返信を表示中 - 1 - 6件目 (全6件中)