READ-ONLY

The forum is now a read-only archive.

For bug reports & platform questions → [email protected]

Our community lives on Discord and YouTube — come join us!

SL Min/Max and ATR Multiples

3 replies

_Cujo

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 97 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #115034

I’m struggling a bit to set what I think are sensible stop losses.

 

This is for the ES. At some point, I had a build error, where it said if I want to auto correct, click yes. I did, so it adjusted my SL to very broad levels, per below, so things like a minimum of 30 ticks, maximum of 300 ticks, and high ATR.

 

My challenge is, imo, a SL of 66 ATR…yeah, is that really a SL? I might as well shove my money in my monitor. I’m used to an ATR being something like (debatable, exactly, but…) 2,3, 3.5…something in there, depending on trend vs reversal, time frame, etc..etc.. Nowhere near 66 ATR. I mean, 66 ATR, that’s what, flash crash?

 

My problem is, if I try and adjust my SL to levels where I think it should be (for something like 1H, trending following strategy on the ES), in the top, where it’s min/max pips…something like don’t know anything really like 12 ticks, 3 points, even that’s fairly lose, tbh, and a maximum of something like 20 ticks, 5 points, it doesn’t work.

 

I also can’t get my ATR multiples to work at anything like something real….

 

What do you use for SL/PT min and Max, and the SL/PT based on ATR multiples??

 

What am I doing wrong….?

 

WJSuA1X.png

 

 

 

 

This is the error I’m getting, the only thing I’m trying to adjust is the SL. Other elements, are (I think…), the same, as instances working fine (ie pretty lose population requirements, no changes to building blocks):

niOYstE.png

0

Tomas Matejka

Administrator, sq-ultimate, 2 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #136617

I have tried to use to ATR to generate strategies and it works well for me.  I see no reason to use such a big ATR multiple.  It should make sense. See screenshots attached

0

_Cujo

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 97 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #136632

Yeah, that’s my point, for some reason it seemed to force me to have such large ATR multiples. I don’t know, now it’s working fine. I think the process of asking you for help makes things work, once I put things in the forum the problem stops…anyway, all good now, thanks…. I don’t know why it wasn’t working with smaller ATR previously.  :unsure:  I got another problem I’m about to put in the Java thread, maybe posting it solves that problem too….eheh.

 

BTW…do you really use .5 ATR as a SL on YM M15? Isn’t that kind of tight, do you find you get stopped out a lot just in noise?

0

Tomas Matejka

Administrator, sq-ultimate, 2 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #136636

With my e-mini (NQ) strategy I use SL only as an account protection not for exiting the trade. Trade is exited using price action. So SL is hit very rarely when platform shuts down or market turns against me fast and hits SL within trade entry bar. I use a fixed $$$ value as it is sufficient in this case. Generally tighter the stop more difficult it is to find some meaningful system (others can have a different experience though)

0

Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)