Evaluating the quality of the Data provided by a Broker
4 replies
Massimo Scapini
4 years ago #279781
Hello,
before going live with my strategies I am starting to evaluate the potential broker I have choosen, on the basis of the quality of the data it provides.
As a source of data I used the MT4 History Center (assuming these are the same data used for the real trading, I hope so …) and I then compared them with the Dukascopy Data (assuming that they are “perfect” :-)).
The results, which you can find in more details in the attached files, can be summarized as follows:
EURUSD:
- Hourly data have an average difference of less than 0.4 Pips, but with a big variance. This is caused mainly by the fact that several bars are reported at :05 min.
- 1M data have an average difference of less than 0.2 Pips, with a very low variance.
SP500 (Broker uses CFD)
- Hourly data have an average difference of approx 6 Pips, with a big variance, mainly caused by a big increase of the difference which occurrend in September.
- The recent difference between 1M data is quite big (more than 11 Pips), with a very low variance.
Unfortunately the 1M data available on MT4 from my broker are only a couple of days long, so I should probably repeat the exercise again in the next days.
Nevertless, I would like to have some hints before proceeding:
- Are this kind of differences “normal” or are they worrying for real trading and should suggest me to find a different broker ?
- Is the “:05” bar issue on EURUSD negligible or can it affect real trading on H1 ?
- Can the big gap on SP500 in recent 1M be caused by some adjustment occurred in September either in Dukascopy data or in data provided by the Broker ?
- Can you suggest some tool to facilitate this kind of analysis ?. Using excel is easy but quite time consuming …
- Further suggestions about how to evaluate the quality of data provided by a Broker
Thank you to whoever can support
0
Daniel
3 years ago #281383
Hi Massimo,
Thank you for your analysis. I just want to mention that as far as I know the MT4 comes not from the broker directly, it comes from the Metatrader historical database itself.
Only in MT5 you can download real broker data. So it would make more sense to choose a MT5 broker if you would like to use the data in SQX and want to compare it with the Dukascopy data, how much they differ.
But I would also like to know if there is a broker which data feed is similar to Dukascopy? For which broker we can use also the Dukascopy data which we have in SQX?
DP
0
Massimo Scapini
3 years ago #281385
Thank you for your input !
I knew that the historical data are downloaded from Metaquotes, but I thoght that this happens only when Broker data are no more available (i.e. more recent data are the Broker’s ones).
Isn’t this the case ? You mean that all the data I see under normal circumstances (i.e. not forcing the data update) are not Broker data but they are all Metaquotes data ?
M
0
Daniel
3 years ago #281386
Thank you for your input ! I knew that the historical data are downloaded from Metaquotes, but I thoght that this happens only when Broker data are no more available (i.e. more recent data are the Broker’s ones). Isn’t this the case ? You mean that all the data I see under normal circumstances (i.e. not forcing the data update) are not Broker data but they are all Metaquotes data ? M
In MT5 the broker can provide still Metaquotes data if they dont have their own available in the past. And in MT4 they are 100& from the Metaquotes server.
Scroll down to the last box:
<p class=”textCommonItem”>The downloaded historical data of MT5 differs from those of MT4. When downloading historical data on MT4, the app downloads the data from the history center of MetaQuotes. Since these are price data provided by MetaQuotes, they will not match the price data provided by your forex broker.</p>
<p class=”textCommonItem”>On the other hand, in MT5, there is no history center. All price data comes directly from each forex broker. However, please note that some of their old data may come from price data provided by MetaQuotes.</p>
DP
0
Massimo Scapini
3 years ago #281414
Thank you !
This is of extreme interest for me !
Does it mean that when I backtest in MT4 using the Strategy Tester I actually do not test the strategy using broker data (or at least the most recent ones) but only using Metaquotes data ??
0
Viewing 4 replies - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)