Here we go again. Please Help!
4 replies
Jason
1 year ago #288721
Another backtests don’t match post.
I’m uploading all the relevant files that I can think of hoping someone can help me out because I don’t know whats going on.
This strat is running off 2 charts, 60m MNQ and 1D MNQ, all data from Tradestation.
Troubleshooting steps:
1. Loaded strat into “Retester” and rebuilt the daily chart from different combinations of minute data (60m & 1m).
a. I did this because I noticed the daily data from Tradestation listed OHLC, Upvolume and OI. Minute data lists OHLC Upvolume and DnVolume. I don’t know why its different. Does anyone know why? I don’t know what OI stands for in this context. Either way the different backtests matched sufficiently
2. Double checked the data in “Data Manager”. I included screenshots of the 1d and 60m data. The bar type is correct, tick size and point value match what Tradestation says they should be and the bar type is corrected listed for Tradestation (this got me in the past)
3. The strat in SQ trades long only, but its coded to take trades in both directions. In Tradestation the strat takes trades in both direction.
4. I checked a backtest on a different strategy from this run and the backtests match.
The session setting is set to no session. I was under the impression when data was downloaded from TS directly, the session was ‘built in’ to the data and therefore no session was required.
Did I get unlucky with 1 run out of a weeks worth of strategy generation? Did I violate some best practice? Am I overlooking something simple? I would appreciate any help anyone can give me.
Thanks,
Jason
0
Tomas Matejka
1 year ago #288750
Hi, would you share the sqx strategy file for analysis? We could check
0
Jason
1 year ago #288767
absolutely
0
Jason
1 year ago #288769
@tomas262 this may be related, but I have another strategy generated from the same settings. Reserved bars is 50 in SQx but GannHiLo is set to 78 which would obviously need 78 reserved bars. Tradestation won’t run the strat until MaxBarsBack is set to 78. I can upload this strategy if you need.
Thanks,
Jason
0
Jason
1 year ago #288821
Viewing 4 replies - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)