WFO , WFM , Simple Opti
3 replies
Matusiak Adrian
11 years ago #113437
Hello,
What is overall trace for creating (optimizing) strategy.
I have generated a few candidates, what next?
Simple Optimalization ? Ok, I get a lot of results, I pick few of them.
Then, what is point to do Walk Forward Optimalization?
WFM as I know will let me know about time for reoptimalization – am I right?
0
Mark Fric
11 years ago #129273
the process I use is described in this article:
https://strategyquant.com/articles/strategy%20building%20process
but it is by no means the only possible process.
Some people put much more weight to testing the promising strategies on demo account and see their performance in reality, instead of on history data in SQ.
Also, it is very important to ensure that the strategy trades more or less the same in MetaTrader as in StrategyQuant – that it opens and closes the trades at the same time.
This could be an issue if you use broker who has different time settings than the data you use in SQ for strategy development – for example if he uses different time zone or has/doesn’t have Sundays.
Mark
StrategyQuant architect
0
Matusiak Adrian
11 years ago #129289
I know it Mark, but I have a bit more complicated questions about steps 😉
1. I generate a bunch of strategies
2. I filter them by doing Robustness test of 300 runs with almost all options checked
3. What now….. Simple Optimization or just start with WFM ?
3a. If Simple Optimization
4a WFM
5a Again Simple Optimization on period discovered by WFM
3b. WFM
4b. Simple Optimization on period discovered by WFM
Does the WFM has to get as many I can of RUNS and OOS % ? (I mean, not step 5 but step 1)
Do I have to check ALL parameters for WFM or none or just a signals like BB Band parameters?
If my strategy uses time range, do I check it also on WFM ? If yes, then does this parameters should be like: start 00:00 , stop :23:00 , step 1:00 or (if my strategy starts eg at 13:00) start: 12:00 , stop 14:00 , step 1:00
What’s more, let’s say that I’ve done WFM and I get “recommended combination: 7 runs / 25% OOS, which means: reoptimizing every 37 days on history of 109 days”
Now, I make Simple Optimalization on last 109 days , right? (or maybe WFO??)
Do I have to split those 109 days into IS and OOS 25% of 109?
What does “runs” have here? Do I have to look at it at all?
Sorry for so much questions, but I’m at level of knowing more WFO and WFM 😉
0
Mark Fric
11 years ago #129375
this is something that is a “know how” developed by every trader, there are no clear rules for everything.
Just use your common sense and experience
I think you don’t need to run Simple optimization before WFM. WFM is used to find out if strategy is robust, so there is no reason to optimize it before WFM.
What’s more, let’s say that I’ve done WFM and I get “recommended combination: 7 runs / 25% OOS, which means: reoptimizing every 37 days on history of 109 days”
Now, I make Simple Optimalization on last 109 days , right? (or maybe WFO??)
Do I have to split those 109 days into IS and OOS 25% of 109?
What does “runs” have here? Do I have to look at it at all?
yes, if WFM result is that you should reoptimize every 37 days with period of 109 days then you should run a simple optimization on history of 109 days (or rouglhy 100 days, the exact number is not that important here.
You don’t need to use OOS for the optimization.
The results you’ll get should be then used for approximately 40 days and then you’ll reoptimize the strategy on the last 109 days again and use the new settings. This is how Walk Forward optimizer works internally too.
Mark
StrategyQuant architect
0
Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
