what’s the difference between risk fixed% of account, of balance?
7 replies
eastpeace
10 years ago #114976
IN QA 4.10.1 , there are 3 risk fixed MM
risk fixed amount
risk fixed % of balance
risk fixed % of account
I think “risk fixed % of account” is like “risk fixed % of account”, but there is a SL in QA.
So, what’s the difference between the last two MMs?
0
geektrader
10 years ago #136293
Read the manual, part 5.2.5, it´s explained there.
0
eastpeace
10 years ago #136299
geektrader,
Thanks for your advice. But SQ’s MM is different with QA’s.
SQ’s “risk fixed % of account” doesn’t have “stoploss in pips”.
QA’s “risk fixed % balance” is like SQ’s “risk fixed % of account”.
There are java code in QA, but I am not a coder 🙂
0
Tomas Matejka
10 years ago #136352
risk fixed % balance simply calculates position size for next trade as a percentage of equity
while risk fixed % of account also takes trade stop-loss size into account (size = max (%) risk / SL) so it is more conservative
0
Mark Fric
10 years ago #136355
yes, exactly – Risk fixed % balance doesn’t consider Stop Loss of an order, it computes the trade size based only on the equity size.
So it can be used to compute MM when you don’t use SL or you use trailing/variable SL which you don’t know beforehand. It is more conservative, and grows as your account grows, but it is not related to an order SL.
Risk fixed % of account takes order SL into consideration, so it is able to compute “exact” position size so that you theoretically shouldn’t lose more than the defined % of equity when trade hits SL – if we abstract from gaps, slippages, etc.
Mark
StrategyQuant architect
0
eastpeace
10 years ago #136362
Thank you all, tomas and Mark.
It’s clear now.
0
Gin
6 years ago #267321
where to get stoploss pips when using risked fixed % ?
SQ strategy already has stop loss
0
hankeys
6 years ago #267325
used SL will lead to a different position? – lower SL = bigger position
You want to be a profitable algotrader? We started using StrateQuant software in early 2014. For now we have a very big knowhow for building EAs for every possible types of markets. We share this knowhow, apps, tools and also all final strategies with real traders. If you want to join us, fill in the FORM.
0
Viewing 7 replies - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)