Issue with Builder “Improve” mode: Returns “No Trades” when replacing Exits
3 replies
jorge castillo
9 months ago #292736
Hi,
I am encountering a persistent issue when using the Builder -> Improve existing strategies mode. It seems like the Improver is unable to generate valid trades when replacing an exit rule, even with the simplest configurations.
The Scenario: I have a Databank of XAUUSD (H1) strategies that currently use “Exit After X Bars”. My goal is to Replace this fixed exit with a standard Stop Loss and Profit Target.
The Problem: When I run the Builder in “Improve” mode (selecting “Improve all strategies in databank”):
Exit Rules: Set to “Replace” -> “Generate Randomly”.
Building Blocks: “Exit After X Bars” unchecked. SL/TP checked.
Result: The process generates 0 strategies. The logs show “No Trades” (100%) or “Initial population filter” rejection due to 0 trades.
Troubleshooting Steps & The Anomaly: I have performed extensive testing to rule out data or parameter errors:
Tested with Fixed Pips (Crucial): To rule out ATR calculation errors or volatility issues, I tried setting the Building Blocks to use Fixed Pips only (e.g., SL 500 pips, TP 1000 pips). Result: Still “No Trades”.
Control Test – “New Strategy” Mode: I opened a New Project using the exact same Data, Symbol Settings (XAUUSD), and Building Blocks (SL/TP). Result: It works perfectly and generates profitable strategies from scratch.
Control Test – AlgoWizard: If I manually edit one of the original strategies in AlgoWizard, delete the “Exit After X Bars” block, and add the SL/TP blocks manually, the backtest works perfectly.
Conclusion: Since the logic works in “New Strategy” mode and “AlgoWizard,” the Data and Strategy logic are valid. The issue seems specific to the “Improve -> Replace” engine, which appears to be breaking the trade execution logic when swapping the exit rules for this batch.
My Settings:
Symbol: XAUUSD, H1.
Data Type: Tested both as “Forex” and “CFD” (Point Value confirmed).
Trading Options: “Max Spread” is disabled/high. “Min distance” is 0. “Max Stop Loss” is disabled.
Filters: All Genetic and Ranking filters were disabled for the test.
Has anyone experienced this behavior where “Improve” yields 0 trades while “New Strategy” with identical settings works fine?
I have attached screenshots of my “Parts to Improve” and “Building Blocks” settings, as well as one of the original .sqx strategies.
Thanks in advance.
0
jorge castillo
9 months ago #292740
Here is the updated and polished version for the StrategyQuant forum. I have included the detail about Fixed Pips failing as well, which is a very strong piece of evidence that the issue is internal to the “Improve” engine and not a calculation error.
Subject: [Issue/Bug] Builder “Improve” mode results in “No Trades” when replacing Exits (Works perfectly in New Strategy mode)
Hi StrategyQuant team,
I am encountering a persistent issue when using the Builder -> Improve existing strategies mode. It seems like the Improver is unable to generate valid trades when replacing an exit rule, even with the simplest configurations.
The Scenario: I have a Databank of XAUUSD (H1) strategies that currently use “Exit After X Bars”. My goal is to Replace this fixed exit with a standard Stop Loss and Profit Target.
The Problem: When I run the Builder in “Improve” mode (selecting “Improve all strategies in databank”):
Exit Rules: Set to “Replace” -> “Generate Randomly”.
Building Blocks: “Exit After X Bars” unchecked. SL/TP checked.
Result: The process generates 0 strategies. The logs show “No Trades” (100%) or “Initial population filter” rejection due to 0 trades.
Troubleshooting Steps & The Anomaly: I have performed extensive testing to rule out data or parameter errors:
Tested with Fixed Pips (Crucial): To rule out ATR calculation errors or volatility issues, I tried setting the Building Blocks to use Fixed Pips only (e.g., SL 500 pips, TP 1000 pips). Result: Still “No Trades”.
Control Test – “New Strategy” Mode: I opened a New Project using the exact same Data, Symbol Settings (XAUUSD), and Building Blocks (SL/TP). Result: It works perfectly and generates profitable strategies from scratch.
Control Test – AlgoWizard: If I manually edit one of the original strategies in AlgoWizard, delete the “Exit After X Bars” block, and add the SL/TP blocks manually, the backtest works perfectly.
Conclusion: Since the logic works in “New Strategy” mode and “AlgoWizard,” the Data and Strategy logic are valid. The issue seems specific to the “Improve -> Replace” engine, which appears to be breaking the trade execution logic when swapping the exit rules for this batch.
My Settings:
Symbol: XAUUSD, H1.
Data Type: Tested both as “Forex” and “CFD” (Point Value confirmed).
Trading Options: “Max Spread” is disabled/high. “Min distance” is 0. “Max Stop Loss” is disabled.
Filters: All Genetic and Ranking filters were disabled for the test.
Has anyone experienced this behavior where “Improve” yields 0 trades while “New Strategy” with identical settings works fine?
I have attached screenshots of my “Parts to Improve” and “Building Blocks” settings, as well as one of the original .sqx strategies.
Thanks in advance.
0
jorge castillo
9 months ago #292747
I agree that, when i try improve 100 strategies on “Strategies to improve” on databank, only received results to improved strategies for the first strategy order by alphabethics.
0
Petr Nadenicek
8 months ago #292867
Hello Jorge,
Please contact us through our support email, [email protected], and include the .cfx configuration of the task along with a few strategies that you want to improve, as mentioned.
I will look into it.
Thank you,
Petr,
SQX Support
0
Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)