READ-ONLY

The forum is now a read-only archive.

For bug reports & platform questions → [email protected]

Our community lives on Discord and YouTube — come join us!

Portfolio Doing Well

151 replies

toddone46

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 76 replies.

Visit profile

11 years ago #113755

The portfolio I developed using StrategyQuant is working very well. I started it in a live account April 1, 2015 and it is up 14% and over 1000 pips.  Drawdown is minimal at 11%, my goal is to have drawdown capped at 20%, but ideally below 15%.  Although it’s too early to conclude success after only 2 months, the strategies’ drawdowns and smooth upward performance results are indicative of the back testing and forward testing results I had.  So it’s looking real good overall.

 

After I made 10%, I doubled the lot size.  This is a test live account (demo account was giving different trade results than the live account so I do not want to rely on a demo account’s results).  I am using a $1,000 account with a .01 micro lot to start, and am now using a .02 micro lot, and will continue to increase as profits grow to compound the returns.

 

Portfolio Details:
1) EURNZD 4hr 

2) GBPJPY 5min
3) AUDNZD 4hr 
4) AUDUSD 30min
5) EURJPY 5min
6) NZDUSD 4hr 
7) GBPUSD daily

 

The attached pic is of when I started this portfolio in a live test account April 1, 2015.  So it has accurate readings related only to this portfolio and filters out previous results from other strategies.  I also have the entire account tracked on MYfxbook (http://www.myfxbook.com/members/PrincipAnalysis/principle-analysis-sq-portfolio/1244436) but this documents the account since its inception which distorts the data related to this portfolio since I tested a grid trading strategy before and it was very wild so I stopped using it.  You can see on the MYfxbook link that the performance became significantly smoothed out once I started using the current StrategyQuant portfolio April 1st though.

 

I just wanted to drop by and post my results and at least short term success in using StrategyQuant to develop my own EAs.  So far so good.  I will be back again later with an updated report.

Attachments in this forum are visible only to Customers.

0

clonex / Ivan Hudec

Customer, bbp_participant, community, sq-ultimate, contributor, author, editor, 268 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133967

So, when you have time lets inspire http://bettersystemtrader.com/016-andrea-unger/ 🙂

0

mikeyc

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 856 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133969

My personal view is you cannot make a long term profitable systems without external data/input (i.e. you can’t just use past prices alone).  External input has to come from economic news, general sentiment and other market drivers.

0

Threshold

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 722 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133977

I know traders using the same technical models for the last 30 years.

0

geektrader

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 503 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133978

“Sometimes”, if it just would BE only “sometimes”… going like that for me since 2011;) Who can show a longer term working portfolio here? Right, no one, and that´s for a reason…


🚀 Unlock Your Edge in Automated Forex Strategy Development 🚀

Historical Forex Data Starting From 1987, 28 Pairs, M1, 99% Error-Free, Lifetime Free Updates

0

Threshold

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 722 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133980

Most of the longer term models are completely public and are extremely simple. Most people already know them. They’re just not very attractive because growth is so slow but if you are managing millions of dollars, then they might be.

Michael Covel’s “Trend Following” Outlines Hedge Funds, some that have been around 30+ years, using the same core technical systems the entire time.

0

Patrick

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 422 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133983

Guys, send us an example of strategy which fail. Then we can hopefully tell you if there is something wrong….

0

tnickel

Customer, bbp_participant, community, sq-ultimate, 494 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133984

Most of the longer term models are completely public and are extremely simple. Most people already know them. They’re just not very attractive because growth is so slow but if you are managing millions of dollars, then they might be.

Michael Covel’s “Trend Following” Outlines Hedge Funds, some that have been around 30+ years, using the same core technical systems the entire time.

Hi Threshold,

can you post us a a long term model that works ?

 

thomas

https://monitortool.jimdofree.com/

0

geektrader

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 503 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133985

Patrick: it´s all good with SQ, that´s not the problem. Backtests between SQ MT4 Live trading match just fine all the time here, but the market changes so drastic each time a new strategy is deployed, they simply fail. And those are DEAD simple strategies, just “3 rules” strategies that pass all robustness tests. But if at all, they work a few weeks at the most during live trading. We can almost conclude: automated trading does NOT really work. Otherwise we would have heaps of successful portfolios being bragged about here.

 

I mean  just look at the article that Mark posted that I quoted already in this thread. Look at their backtests (almost a straight line for 14 years), then look at their live performance:)

Article with backtest: https://strategyquant.com/articles/strategyquant-success-story

Performance since they are live trading that “great” portfolio: http://www.myfxbook.com/members/strategyquant/portfolio-1/1188718

 

That´s exactly what everyone else here is experiencing – and actually everyone in automated trading. There are countless EA forums, yet you will not find a SINGLE EA that works (but they all look great in the backtests of course).

 

Tell me, where are the successful automated traders? The hedge-funds you mention make their money from commissions of their investors, barely by their performance as they almost never outperform the stock market. And if you say it´s mostly about our strategies being “wrong” in some way, then why not show everyone here YOUR portfolio of successful automated LIVE trading? Would be great to see how well you do with it and would love to be educated different in that something like automated trading will ever work. I´ve spent the last 8 years of my life almost SOLELY on automated trading, yet never made it with ANY strategy (regardless if SQ or not) longer than a few weeks / months.


🚀 Unlock Your Edge in Automated Forex Strategy Development 🚀

Historical Forex Data Starting From 1987, 28 Pairs, M1, 99% Error-Free, Lifetime Free Updates

0

mikeyc

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 856 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133987

It’s a bit like the Fermi Paradox.  There are believed to be 100,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 stars in the universe. Yet, we’ve never been contacted by aliens.

 

There’s probably as many automated trading systems out there, and not one profitable long term. 😉

 

However there IS big money to be made.

 

Sell books

Sell software

Become a broker

Become an affiliate.

 

😀

0

RJL

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 67 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133988

Wow, the skepticism and negativity in here is dismal! 

 

If we were to just focus on the portfolio of this particular thread http://www.myfxbook.com/members/PrincipAnalysis/principle-analysis-sq-portfolio/1244436 then what exactly is so wrong with it?

 

It’s not even been running a year people!

 

There was a period of stagnation from June 26th to Septermber 8th. Less than two and half months.

 

And then another period of stagnation from September 8th until now. Who knows how much longer it will stagnate…but who knows what the maximum stagnation was during testing?? Only the creator of the portfolio.

 

I’ve seen countless strategies with long periods of stagnation. Even with a large portfolio of strategies 100 days + of stagnation has been common. That’s over 3 months of a portfolio not making new highs!

 

TIP: if you don’t like stagnation and slow gains…create more profitable strategies to fill in the gaps. Simple.

 

And no, I completely disagree that people successful portfolios are going to brag about it. Not everyone is like that.

 

Also, by all accounts, the owner of this particular portfolio has already said the results are good enough for him and in line with his own expectations.

 

I don’t know what the big deal is and I think everyone just needs to get back to building new and better strategies.

0

munchie

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 63 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133989

Geektrader: my experience in automated trading is not as extensive as yours or some in this forum so you maybe correct here. I disagree with the point that hedge funds make money from commissions irrespective of performance. I agree that hedge funds are having a bad time now, you only have to look at the performance of one of the largest listed hedge funds in the world(man group) to see this. They are, however, very much performance remunerated as they have a high watermark to beat before their funds can start charging performance fees. The commissions is secondary and represent more of revenue for a broker than a fund manager such as man group. No doubt I will discover for myself the negatives in auto mated trading as discussed in this thread in due course tho more frequent and thorough re-optimisation of profitable strategies may be the answer to a more consistent upward equity curve imho.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

0

Patrick

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 422 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133990

Geektratder:

Some strategies are earning, some not. There are mistakes in SQ, some strategies are spread sensitive, some are curvefitted. Our goal is to avoid all of these things.

If you send strategy, i can at least try to tell you what i think is wrong, if you  will not, i cannot help you-i cannot give you my strategies….or tell you- do it like this.

 

Some people who are succes dont want to share their results. Also we dont know whats wrong with portfolio from the article, may be the MM was changed, strategies were changed, we dont know how big is risk etc 

 

If i build strategy with stagantion 300 days in history it can happen strategy has stgnation 100 days…it is normal for H1 strategies.

 

Mikyec: For example breakouts are based on price action and it works great. So no need data feed to SQ, also sometimes we expect for example Euro to go up and it goes down so data feed to SQ is not solution. They are some algorithms in past, so we are trying to find them-historical data is all we need.

0

Threshold

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 722 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #133992

Heres a long term model that works on most any commodity/metal/stock index/currency pair. Its in my public and private portfolio right now. It was first shown to me by someone whos been using it all his life (hes in his 50s now) and I made several adaptations/personal changes on it. Since it trades daily and its on only about 8 pairs , it only had about 25 signals per year. You can increase trade frequency and smooth portfolio curve by adding indexes and commodities, bonds, metals. That’s right, these systems work on anything.

**(always Daily bars based)**

Concept: Markets contract and expand. When they contract and go sideways for a while, they usually breakout after then start to trend.

First step, wait for ADX(measures trend) to get to a very low value. Below 20 is a generally good target but for some pairs you want it even lower. You can filter even more by waiting for a low volatility as well.
Set a variable to “true” once that happens.
Then if variable is true start waiting for market to make a breakout. You can wait for it to break via upper/lower bollingerband, a 20 day high, 100 day high, a volatility break out. Whatever, it doesn’t matter. Then start following the trend and apply money management.
For some pairs/metals/indexes its better to FADE the signal and wait for a FALSE breakout and trend the opposite way. Depends on the pair. You’ll have to find that out.

Another very simple one is to wait for market to be trending WITH the 200 Daily moving average but pull back to under the RSI 35 then BUY with the trend. (You’ll have to find the right rules but its similar to what I said above).

Both those are trend following systems

This will always work and keep working on all markets because its TRUE about markets. The concept makes sense. It has logic. Markets contract in volatility and go sideways then breakout and trend. Or they are already trending and pullback then trend some more. I ask myself if I am going to use a system DO I UNDERSTAND IT? Does it make sense? Why does it work? If it has some ridiculous combinations of indicators and it doesnt make sense, I throw it away.

The signals are slow and I know everybody wants a scalp system here with 80% wins and 100% return in a month/per quarter/per year but those are the types of systems that dont work very long and its also why I’m not afraid to tell you what I’m using. I have quite a few more systems incubating waiting to be added to the portfolio that will greatly increase its trade frequency and win% all still D1 based for 2016.

All these robust “true about markets” systems can be found in loads of books and they *still work*. Generally books just give you the basic model, but you can improve upon them with thinking and testing. Get the *real books* written by *professional traders with 30 years trading in markets* (Larry Williams, Richard Weissman, Howard Brandy, Van Tharp, Linda Raschke, Perry Kaufman). Theres LOADS of real American traders with decades in the market who enjoy teaching and spreading knowledge that wrote books with real systems in them and the authors don’t even need the money. Most of those people made millions in the market before ever writing.
Don’t get the 1$ ebooks written by some kid in kazakhstan or Kenya. 😛 I generally stay away from the “psychology trading” books. I strictly look for ones with systems in them for ideas/inspiration written by traders that are already proven/well known. (Kevin Davey is another 1)

*This post has nothing to do with the thread’s topic/portfolio. It was just because someone said ‘no systems work very long’ (his observation is probably based on retail trading systems for sale for 50 dollars or myfxbook retail trader systems) and the statement was factually untrue. tnickle wanted an example for long term systems that have been working for decades.*

Hope it helps tnickle. 🙂 Looking forward to 2016.

0

tnickel

Customer, bbp_participant, community, sq-ultimate, 494 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #134014

@threshold,

thanks,

so we need only data with long period.

Example from 1980 and import this data into the SQ

 

The SQ should able to find such systems.

 

 

At yahoo I can get data with Daily timeframes. But I think I need data with M1 timeframes??

It is so ?

 

thomas

https://monitortool.jimdofree.com/

0

Threshold

Customer, bbp_participant, community, 722 replies.

Visit profile

10 years ago #134019

They were made with EA Wizard. SQ wasn’t flexible enough. SQ4 will be.
My point/post wasn’t really about data. Mostly about systems that are intelligent in design and are true about general market structure last the longest.
In the case of using SQ, ‘intelligent design’ isn’t an option (its just randomly putting things together in a limited framework) so the best way to force it to look for “general truths” about the market is: 1) longer data, 2)Multiple data.

If you have any other questions PM them so we don’t detract from the original thread.

0

Viewing 15 replies - 76 through 90 (of 151 total)

← 1 2 3 … 5 6 7 … 9 10 11 →