Issue: Difference between report MyFXbook and it’s .CSV in Quant Analyzer
5 replies
Simo Ilmari
6 years ago #203916
Hello, I recently imported the .CSV of a statement of my strategy 2016 from MyFxBook, but on Quant Analyzer I have some difference in performance % and money.
On Myfxbook I had a +30,47% and a DD% of 9,6%, after import to Quantum Analyzer I have +28,46% and DD% 9,9%
My account is in EUR and I see that Quantanalyzer is in USD (% or PIPs) , could be this the problem?
I attach two screenshots to show what’s happening and hope to solve this.
Than You,
Cordially, Simoilmari.
(Sorry for my English…)
tomas262
6 years ago #204015
Hello,
since the numbers are quite close that small difference could be caused by numbers rounding. If you attach the actual csv zipped we can investigate deeper
Simo Ilmari
6 years ago #204083
Hello, thank for your answer, I will give You 2 statement, because in one there was pending orders so looking at other working statement there was not pending orders, I eliminated the pending orders, but the result is the same…
Here I attach both statement of the same strategy
Thank You !
Simo.
Simo Ilmari
6 years ago #204086
Hello notch, I see that importing from detailed statement from MT4 I had NO problems, so when I have problem importing, I check the number of columns , I check size,open price, close price are written.
A good statement you could modify to import to Quant Analyzer is made from the MT4 detailed statement.
Sorry for my English, I hope you understand me, If you want , send me your statement (*.zip) that you can’t import to QA and I will check where is the problem, but as you can read, I had equally some problem… as I have not the same results of the Myfxbook (and real results , profit % and DD% )
Simo.
Simo Ilmari
6 years ago #204148
Hello I will try in these days and I will reply…
Simo Ilmari
6 years ago #217764
Hello, I want to tell you that I tried once but with no result and at the same time i tried to modify one of my report without success.
You can do , or try to do this: Make a report from an MT4 , demo,real or strategy report , than change (overwrite) the orders, date, size etc…
I’m very busy this week but i hope not forget your issue, I will try again, please try to do what I wrote and please if you have success write here !
Viewing 5 replies - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)